Fr. Paul Kramer discussed how the Third Secret of Fatima references the fact that the Catholic Church will appear to become “extinguished” during his presentation at last week’s 2026 Rome Life Forum.

While the Third Secret of Fatima (which has not been fully revealed by the Vatican but has been disclosed to certain priests) warns of frightening physical chastisements such as “the inundation of entire continents,” it warns of something “far more frightful,” said Fr. Kramer, referring to a comment on the secret by the late Fr. Malachi Martin.

Kramer pointed out that Sister Lucy couldn’t initially bring herself to write down the secret. “That’s how terrible the secret is,” he said.

Alluding to the fact that this secret pertained to the Catholic Church, Kramer stressed that many Catholics would have the impression that it is “against the faith” because it “seems to deny the visibility and indefectibility of the Church.”

However, this comes from a “simplistic, fundamentalist understanding of the catechism,” said Kramer, who throughout his talk emphasized that the Church will continue to survive, even when its visibility becomes obscured.

He went on to declare that the Third Secret speaks of the emergence of a “counterfeit church” that will “seem like the true Church.”

“That’s at the heart of the Third Secret, what makes it so terrifying,” Kramer said.

He referenced the disclosure of Cardinal Mario Luigi Ciappi, who once confessed in a letter that “In the Third Secret, among other things, it is predicted that the great apostasy in the Church will begin at the top.”

Kramer hinted at the fact that he believes this has already begun to occur. Sr. Jeanne of the Nativity spoke of a time when the Church “will sink so deeply and become so obscured by its enemies that she will at last seem to be extinguished.”

“It will appear as if the succession of Peter and the Apostles has expired,” and Sr. Jeanne also saw a vision of the Church’s “new constitution.”

Kramer pointed out that through the Synod of Synodality prelates “are trying surreptitiously to change the constitution of the church.”

As a part of this apparent “death” of the Church, the Mass itself will be altered so that it is no longer an actual, valid Mass but a Protestant deformation, as Julie Marie Jahenny prophesied, according to Kramer.

When this occurs, he said, “the graces received from the celebration of the Mass will cease,” and then “the full force of the threatened chastisement by Our Lady of Fatima” and the Blessed Mother in her other apparitions, “all those horrific chastisements will be meted out on the earth.”

Kramer went on to stress that, as theologians have explained, just because the Church will always be visible doesn’t mean that visibility will always be obvious. 

“The visibility could be greatly obscured,” Kramer said. He referenced St. Robert Bellarmine, who has explained that during the time of the great tribulation, “the geographical extension of the Church could be greatly reduced to one region of the earth” and the rest of the earth will be in total apostasy.

For example, when Our Lady said that in Portugal the doctrine of the faith will always be preserved, “expert commentators have pointed out that strongly implies that in many other places the faith will completely disappear.”

Kramer concluded by assuring Catholics that, when a doubtful pope does appear, they are not obligated to submit to him.

“When a man who is supposedly the pope who has had an election of questionable validity or is guilty of manifesting … vehement suspicion of heresy or violent suspicion of heresy, it is the right of the Catholic to withdraw submission” to the man, Kramer said.

“You are not judged a schismatic for withdrawing obedience from such a questionable, doubtful pope” while adhering to Catholic teaching, said Kramer, clarifying that this is very different from committing the Protestant error of reinterpreting doctrine. 

“We must obey God rather than men,” he concluded.