Magna Quaestio

The Letters 124 and 126 in Which St. Bernard of Clairvaux 'Photographed' the 2013 Coup d'État

Here is a concise summary (384 characters): Based on the letters of Saint Bernard defending the rights of Pope Innocent II against the antipope Anaclet (1130), Andrea Cionci draws a parallel with 2013: Benedict XVI not having renounced the Petrine 'munus,' his pontificate remained valid. The election of Francis was therefore canonically null. He was, like Anaclet, and as the antipope Leo is today, his successor, a usurper, for there can be only one pope at a time.

The Inquiry into Andrea Cionci's Analysis of the Papacy Reignites: The Scholar Received a Second Time at the Vatican

We converse with the scholar to better understand his independent analysis on the current legitimacy of the Papacy

Is the Benedict XVI Case Closed? New Documents, Interrogations and Investigations Reignite the Debate in the Vatican

Fact-Checking the "Pope Emeritus"

Benedict XVI's Brilliant Canonical Maneuver to Outwit the Anti-Church

More facts, just plain facts. Because the Catholic faith is built on facts – the Incarnation, the Resurrection, the Ascension – and if we pay attention to the facts, we will be able to hear what the Holy Spirit is saying to the churches (Rev 3:13).

Andrea Cionci publishes emails received from Card. Robert Sarah: "We hope his book Ratzinger Code will enlighten consciences"

The cardinal had already expressed himself in 2021 by blessing the journalist's work. It is time to enforce the rights of the last true pope: Benedict XVI

Andrea Cionci releases correspondence with Cardinal Robert Sarah regarding the investigation into Benedict XVI's resignation and the validity of the 2025 conclave.

Texas Bishop Gracida dies at 102 – considered Francis an antipope, Benedict’s resignation invalid

Gracida was the only bishop in the United States and one of only a few in the world to state publicly that Francis was not Pope.

Bishop Gracida, WWII hero, a saintly man & one of the greatest bishops of our time, dies at 102

I just spoke with a close friend of Bishop Rene Gracida who was with him when he peacefully passed away this morning in his home. We both agreed he was a saintly man and one of the greatest bishops of our time.

Fatima Priests Gruner and Kramer: Benedict’s Resignation Invalid - Francis was NOT Pope

John-Henry Westen speaks with Paul Kramer about the controversy surrounding the resignation of Pope Benedict XVI and whether it met the requirements of canon law. The discussion centers on the distinction between munus (office) and ministerium (ministry), and how that difference could affect the legitimacy of later papal claims. The conversation explores broader theological questions about papal authority, heresy, and continuity in Church leadership. Implications for the pontificates of Pope Francis and Pope Leo XIV are also examined, underscoring ongoing debates within Catholic circles over authority, clarity, and fidelity to tradition.

Liz Yore: Globalists used NSA spying, SWIFT, ‘Catholic Spring’ to force out Benedict XVI

Yore has exposed what she calls a full-scale globalist coup to oust Pope Benedict XVI and install a more compliant pontiff aligned with the UN’s Agenda 2030.

What Traditional Catholics Refuse to Understand

Too many complain about Bergoglio while refusing to reckon with his patent illegitimacy to the Chair of Peter

"Magna Quaestio": How a Latin Formula Became the Banner of a Pontifical Challenge

Since the resignation of Benedict XVI in 2013, a question has divided part of the Catholic Church: is the See of Peter legitimately occupied? A Latin expression, popularised from 2021 onwards, has come to crystallise this incendiary debate: the Magna Quaestio.