«Dear Father, I urgently need your help. How should I respond to a heretic who claims that Benedict XVI resigned from the ministry but not from the munus, thus not renouncing the papacy?»
To this question, posed by a reader on the internet page Amici Domenicani on 29 September 2023, Father Angelo Bellon replies:
«My dearest, I do not think one can define as heretical someone who asserts that, by renouncing the papacy, Benedict XVI only resigned from the ministry and not from the munus. If we bear in mind that the munus was conferred upon him by the Lord through the election of the cardinals, then there is no way around it. Once invested with such authority, one cannot remove it from oneself.
There is no issue in having an emeritus pope who retains the petrine munus but has renounced its exercise. Equally, there is no issue in having a pope who retains the petrine munus without exercising it and another pope who possesses and exercises the petrine munus. There would not be two popes to whom obedience is due, but only one: the reigning one.»
A Single Petrine Chair and the Case of Benedict XVI
Father Bellon asserts that, by renouncing only the ministry, Benedict XVI remains pope. This is correct. He is, however, mistaken when he believes that the pope cannot freely and explicitly renounce his munus, for this is the only condition stipulated by canon 332, paragraph 2, for the validity of his abdication. He is also mistaken in claiming that two popes can coexist simultaneously: Scripture, Tradition, the Magisterium, canon law, and even logic teach that the Church can have but one and only vicar of Christ.
The petrine munus neither divides nor multiplies. Any cardinal elected while the pope is still alive and has not abdicated is an illegitimate antipope, in accordance with number 76 of Universi Dominici Gregis, which states that an election conducted in a manner other than that prescribed is null and void, without the need for any declaration to that effect, and thus confers no rights upon the person elected.
To affirm, therefore, that there are two popes, both invested with the petrine munus, one of whom exercises it while the other remains quiescent, is pure phantastical theology. Evidently, however incredible it may seem, there are still those who refuse to consider the findings of Dr. Andrea Cionci’s Codice Ratzinger investigation.
In the interview with Peter Seewald, published in Italian in 2016 under the title Last Conversations, Benedict XVI is asked: «Do you see yourself as the last pope of the old world or the first of the new?» He replies: «I would say both.» To which the journalist responds: «As a bridge, a kind of connecting element between the two worlds.» And the pope comments: «I no longer belong to the old world, but the new one has not yet begun.»
Pope Benedict declares himself to be the last pope of the past and the first of the future, thus a bridge between the old and the new: namely, the pontiff of the present world and, in reality, still reigning, in flesh and blood. He reiterates this when, in response to the question of whether he was indeed the last to represent the figure of the pope as we have known it until now, according to the prophecy of Malachy, he answers: «Everything is possible.» He suggests that he is the last pope validly elected in accordance with the norms of canon law and the last to embody the type of successor to Peter in conformity with the authentic tradition of the Catholic Church.
Pope Ratzinger, three years after his declaratio, still presents himself as the successor of Peter, indeed as the recapitulation of the events and nature of the Church itself. The past and the future of Catholicism find in him the certainty of Peter’s profession of faith and the rock upon which the Church, holy, catholic, and apostolic, is built.
Catholic confession, in its authentic and typical expression, gathers itself in the pontificate of Benedict XVI. To that faith which he professed, to that faith which he defended, we must still remain bound in order to be Catholic.
Nevertheless, even due to the culpable negligence of the cardinals, the general indifference of the Catholic world, and the distorted interpretation given by the media worldwide, the declaratio by which Benedict XVI voluntarily allowed himself to be deposed in an impeded sede — a final act of abandonment to Christ in faith for the salvation of the Church — has remained almost buried, like smoldering embers beneath the ashes of his pontificate, set ablaze by circles of traitorous and slanderous ecclesiastics.
After him, the democratic mask with which the antipope Bergoglio was immediately presented to the world, across all networks, as the pope of the people, the humble shepherd of the last and the poor, the tireless parish priest of the universal Church, has served to conceal the true features of the usurper of the petrine throne: a despotic authoritarian, a cunning manipulator of the word of God, a Luciferian perverter of Catholic doctrine and the Church of the Lord, a reckless dissolvent of the Magisterium of the true popes who preceded him, the head of a schismatic anti-church still raw and unrefined, delivered to his successor Prevost for completion.
The Reform of the Synod: A Juridical Refounding
A paradigmatic example of this diabolical artistry is the apostolic constitution Episcopalis communio, with which Bergoglio reformed the synod of bishops. It represents the birth certificate of the synodal church.
To support this thesis, I propose two elements. The first is as follows: Episcopalis communio is an apostolic constitution. The choice of this type of document already makes it clear that it constitutes a true and proper founding of the synod. The apostolic constitution, in fact, belongs to the supreme Magisterium and to the great universal legislation of the Church. It is the most authoritative, significant, and solemn legislative and doctrinal document of a pope.
The value of the constitution by which Bergoglio reforms the synod of bishops is also understood in relation to the document by which Pope Montini, on 15 September 1965, erected the synod of bishops. At the time, Paul VI employed a motu proprio apostolic letter, that is, of his own initiative: a document far more agile and circumscribed than an apostolic constitution, often used by popes to address specific issues of ecclesiastical discipline.
Paul VI had created the synod of bishops to promote the communal participation of bishops from around the world, so that they might advise the pope on the most important questions and decisions concerning the universal Church. Pope John Paul II had established the juridical form of the synod of bishops in canons 342 to 348 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law.
On 29 September 2006, Pope Benedict XVI had approved the latest edition of the Ordo Synodi, that is, the regulations of the synod of bishops, without, however, making any changes to the juridical status or theological meaning already set forth by the Code of Canon Law. Bergoglio, instead, constitutes the synod of bishops anew, altering its form and content, while maintaining some superficial resemblance to the norms governing the conduct of assemblies.
With this, the second element that proves the refounding of the synod of bishops to be the official birth certificate of Bergoglio’s church is already anticipated. In the conclusions of the constitution Episcopalis communio, Bergoglio writes explicitly: «With the present apostolic constitution, all contrary provisions are abrogated, in particular all provisions of canon law and of the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches on the synod of bishops that do not agree, in whole or in part, with the present constitution.»
The Synod Before the Reform: Canonical Framework
Thus are abrogated the articles that governed the synod of bishops, established by Pope Paul VI in 1965, and the regulations of the synod issued by Benedict XVI in 2006 and in force until then. To understand how radical Bergoglio’s reform is and how he uses it to set in motion the synodal process of a new, entirely synodal Church, it is useful to explain what the synod of bishops was before Bergoglio, through a descriptive synthesis of canons 342–348, which outline its juridical capacity, theological value, and functioning.
According to the Code of Canon Law, first, from a juridical standpoint, the synod of bishops is not an instrument of communal governance of the Church, for it possesses no legislative power. Decisions are made by the pope, who in certain cases transfers his own deliberative power to the synod so that it may promulgate decisions or decrees.
From a theological standpoint, the synod is not a miniature council, since it reaffirms the centrality of the primacy of the successor of Peter, connects the college of bishops with the pope, and manifests the responsibility of the universal Church toward the entire world.
With regard to its structure, the synod is coordinated by a general secretariat, which serves to prepare the synods and accompany their proceedings. The general secretariat is assisted by a council of bishops, whose purpose is to know and relate the requests and intentions of the various dioceses throughout the entire Catholic Church. Yet even the council of bishops is not a governing body alongside the pope. It is not a permanent synod.
In summary, the synod of bishops, as governed by canon law before Bergoglio’s reform, can never be a permanent synod with the power to make laws at its own discretion. Indeed, only the college of bishops with the pope, in its totality and unity, holds the right to exercise its jurisdiction. Such jurisdiction is expressed in the council or in the practical action of all the Catholic bishops of the entire world, in accordance with the doctrine of Vatican II expressed in Lumen gentium 22.
The college of bishops, commented Cardinal Ratzinger in 1985, does not have the power to transfer its own right to the synod of bishops, for it is not a positive right, that is, established by men, but a right that descends directly from God. Such juridical power, therefore, belongs solely to the apostolic college and thus to the episcopal college, from which it derives, and can be exercised only in the aforementioned cases.
The Project of an Entirely Synodal Church
Now, keeping these notes in mind, let us examine the guiding idea behind Bergoglio’s reform. Through his own words, we know that, in general, «it is precisely the synodal path that is the path God expects of the Church of the third millennium.» Bergoglio further states: «In particular, the synod of bishops is the point of convergence of this dynamic of listening conducted at all levels of the life of the Church.»
In Bergoglio’s mind, then, God expects the Church of the third millennium to become entirely synodal; and he himself, Bergoglio, places the synod of bishops, as he has reformed it, at the helm of this process of transformation of the Church. Yet he does not ask the shepherds to exercise the task of safeguarding the good deposit of the faith, which in the Catholic Church distinguishes the service of the order of bishops by virtue of the mandate given by Jesus to Peter and the other apostles. Bergoglio asks the synod of bishops to be a mere instrument of listening, gathering, and synthesizing the voices of the people of God.
Two: from the very title of Bergoglio’s document, The Communion of Bishops, Episcopalis communio, he cunningly alludes to the hierarchical, sacramental, and communal structure of the Catholic Church, but this is done solely to deceive the faithful. The true intent of Bergoglio, in fact, is to strip the bishops, successors of the apostles, of their proper ministry: that of guardians of the faith, shepherds capable of exhorting, teaching, and leading to Christ, the good shepherd, the flock that belongs to him.
The Argentine antipope does not desire that the bishops commit themselves to correcting the errors of the faithful and defending them from the attacks of wolves, perhaps at the cost of their own lives. On the contrary, by subverting the role of the sacred order instituted by the Lord Jesus, Bergoglio entrusts the college of bishops with modest tasks of accompaniment and support, predominantly human, psychological, and friendly in nature.
Bergoglio does not have in mind the Church that Christ founded upon the profession of faith of the apostle Peter and entrusted to the college of the apostles. He wishes instead to dismantle, piece by piece, the entire edifice, and he begins by dismantling its apostolic foundations.
Naturally, this destructive method is masked by an abuse of the Magisterium of the Church that is as skillful as it is wicked. Indeed, in order to justify his own choices that are not in conformity with Catholic faith, Bergoglio pretends to ground the future of the synod of bishops and of the synodal Church upon the solid foundations of Catholicism. Thus he cites extensive passages from Vatican II, mentions the work of Paul VI, alludes to the interventions of John Paul II, and refers to the regulations of Pope Benedict XVI. Yet a clumsy, barely concealed duplicity is already evident in the laudatory style with which Bergoglio refers to the past: it is the classic faux diplomatic attitude, typical of seasoned ecclesiastical hypocrisy and high prelatic cunning.
The purpose of this nauseating performance is to make the faithful believe that between the work of the false pope Bergoglio and that of the true popes of the past, up to Benedict XVI, there exists an organic doctrinal and disciplinary continuity. When, however, the Argentine antipope pushes the Catholic Church into the synodal future he has imagined, he lays the new foundations for the reconstruction of the synod of bishops solely upon his own putative Magisterium.
In the decisive passages of Episcopalis communio, Bergoglio cites only himself, that is, his own previous documents, without assuming the historical, theological, and doctrinal depth of the Magisterium of the Church, which includes Vatican II and the postconciliar popes. And thus he does not truly adhere to Catholic tradition, which traces back to the apostles and to Christ Himself. In a word, at the foundation of the reform of the synod of bishops and of the synodal Church there are not Scripture, Tradition, and the Magisterium of the popes, but only Bergoglio and his ideas.
The Sensus Fidei and the Role of the Faithful
Let us take an example, perusing the text. «It is certainly true,» writes Bergoglio, «as the Second Vatican Council teaches, that when bishops teach in communion with the Roman Pontiff, they must be listened to by all with reverence as witnesses to the divine and Catholic truth. And the faithful must assent to the judgment of their bishop, given in the name of Christ in matters of faith and morals, and adhere to it with religious obedience of the spirit.»
Here, by quoting Lumen gentium 25, the Argentine prelate reaffirms that the role of the college of bishops with the pope is founded upon traditional Magisterium and invites the faithful to the necessary attitude of religious obedience to the bishops who, in communion with the pope, teach truths of faith and morals.
«But it is equally true,» Bergoglio continues, quoting John Paul II, «that the life of the Church and life within the Church is for every bishop the condition for the exercise of his mission to teach.» And here, with an adversative conjunction artfully placed, the antipope turns the page and induces us to take note of the new theme, the one that truly lies close to his heart: the mutual dependence between the ministry of the bishop and the life of the Church, a condition, he says, indispensable for the episcopal exercise of the teaching function.
But beware: the path is not yet complete; there is still one more leap forward to be made. Bergoglio is interested, in fact, in leading the reflection onto the terrain of an equality between bishops and the faithful with regard to the truths of faith, and thus in legitimizing and obliging the bishops to move from their task of guardians of the orthodoxy of the apostolic faith to that of mere condescending companions of the people of God.
To do this, he first cites Vatican II and recalls that the people of God, in its entirety, by virtue of the sensus fidei that belongs to all the faithful, cannot err in believing in matters of faith and morals. The passage from Lumen gentium 12, inserted at this point, is, however, the theological-doctrinal springboard that Bergoglio uses to cast the episcopal sacred order into the open sea of synodality, establishing within it the criterion for discerning the truths of faith and morals and forcing the bishops to learn to keep afloat in these waters lest they drown.
Here, then, is the citation of the conciliar text: «The entire body of the faithful, anointed as they are by the Holy One, cannot err in matters of belief. This characteristic they manifest through a supernatural sense of the faith of all the people when, “from the bishops to the last of the lay faithful,” they show universal agreement in matters of faith and morals.»
Attention: we must now clarify the issue precisely in order to expose the deception underlying this apparently harmless text. The last true pope, Benedict XVI, on several occasions warned the Church against a possible and dangerous erroneous and manipulative understanding of Catholic teaching regarding the sensus fidei and the sensus fidelium.
In 2012, for example, on the occasion of the plenary session of the International Theological Commission, Pope Ratzinger explained that the sensus fidei constitutes in the believer a kind of supernatural instinct, endowed with a vital connaturality with the very object of faith. It is a criterion for discerning whether a truth belongs to the vital deposit of apostolic tradition.
The pope then proceeded to comment that today, however, it is particularly important to specify the criteria that allow one to distinguish authentic sensus fidelium from its counterfeits. In reality, it is not a kind of ecclesiastical public opinion, nor is it possible to invoke it to contest the teachings of the Magisterium, for the sensus fidei cannot develop authentically in the believer except insofar as he participates fully in the life of the Church. And this requires responsible adherence to its Magisterium and to the deposit of the faith.
From this it is clear that using the category of the supernatural sense of the faith of the people of God, as Bergoglio does, to legitimize the arbitrary transformation of the truths of Catholic faith and morals, their replacement with anti-evangelical proposals, or even their suppression, is an inadmissible deception.
On the other hand, it is equally unacceptable for those who, rejecting Bergoglio’s counterfeits, feel authorized and almost justified in no longer obeying even the authoritative Magisterium of Pope Benedict XVI.
As stated earlier, Bergoglio uses a text from the Second Vatican Council in order to subject the episcopal order and the activity of governance and teaching of the successors of the apostles to the exercise of the sensus fidei of the people of God, thus opposing the public opinion of the faithful to Catholic doctrine.
For example, even if the majority of the synodal assembly approved the blessing of same-sex couples — not the individual homosexual persons who exercise self-mastery and make their journey of conversion to the Lord — and even if the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith ratified such a liturgical gesture, this does not mean that the blessing of same-sex couples can be approved by God, for it is in contradiction with Scripture and with the Magisterium of the Church, which has always recognized it as a grave sin. God does not bless sin, which instead requires an exacting journey of repentance and conversion.
As we have seen, with a clever sleight of hand, the Argentine antipope has replaced conciliar doctrine with his own revolutionary ideas, inserting into his apostolic constitution passages from his own discourse to the new bishops of 2013 and from his encyclical Evangelii gaudium, thus sealing with his own mark the document of birth of the synod, reformed in his image.
The Role of the Bishops Redefined
Bergoglio establishes the new kind of service that the bishop must henceforth exercise and writes: «The bishop, for this reason, is called to walk ahead, indicating the way; to walk in the midst, strengthening the people of God in unity; to walk behind, so that no one is left behind, but above all to follow the scent that the people of God has for finding new paths.»
«A bishop who lives in the midst of his faithful has his ears open to hear what the Spirit says to the Churches and the voice of the sheep, even through those diocesan bodies that have the task of advising the bishop, promoting loyal and constructive dialogue.»
Finally, placing his own thought once more at the foundation of the synodal reform, Bergoglio concludes: «Although in its composition it takes the form of an essentially episcopal body, the synod does not therefore live separated from the rest of the faithful. On the contrary, it is an instrument suited to giving voice to the entire people of God, precisely through the bishops constituted by God, authentic guardians, interpreters, and witnesses of the faith of the whole Church, showing itself from assembly to assembly as an eloquent expression of synodality as a constitutive dimension of the Church.»
By citing his own discourse for the fiftieth anniversary of the synod of bishops, Bergoglio thus declares the transformation of the synod of bishops to have been accomplished: from an organ of counsel, fraternal formation, and correction among the bishops of the world, in support of the pope on the most important questions of the universal Church and for the strengthening of the announcement of the Gospel to the entire world, to a mere instrument of democratic representation of the people of God.
Thus the Church, the mystical body of Christ, hierarchically constituted under the guidance of the bishops with the pope, the beloved Catholic Church that founds the communion of its members upon communion in the Eucharistic body of Christ and obedience to His word, is supplanted by an ecclesial subject constitutively synodal, in which the bishops are called to become, from assembly to assembly, «an eloquent expression» of synodality. It is precisely in this reduction of theirs to exemplary witnesses of mutual dialogue, reciprocal listening, and benevolent welcome that, according to Bergoglio, they fulfill their ministry as authentic guardians, interpreters, and witnesses of the faith of the whole Church.
This is enough to make one’s head spin. Such an inversion of roles, such an impoverishment and distortion of the sacred episcopal ministry could not be better represented than by the image of a bishop who, from shepherd of the flock, is degraded to the role of sheepdog: protective, loyal, with a strong sense of duty, called to lead the sheep, to guard them, to indicate the way, to walk in their midst, and to walk behind, above all to follow the scent that the people of God has for finding new paths.
No less significant is the image of the public relations promoter, the group animator who, precisely by doing so, according to what the antipope Bergoglio maintains, listens to what the Spirit says to the Churches and to the voice of the sheep, which in Bergoglio’s mind evidently coincide.
What cannot be accepted in the slightest is that the reasonable and minimal human virtues required of a shepherd rise to the criteria of justice for his suitability and for the authenticity of the sacred ministry that Jesus Christ instituted for the announcement of the Gospel and of the true faith to all the nations of the earth.
On the contrary, this reform is part of a process by which Bergoglio intends to reshape profoundly all ecclesial structures so that they may become more missionary, as he wrote in Evangelii gaudium, that is, more sensitive to the needs of people, more open to what is new, more flexible in an era of rapid transformations. Being sensitive to people, open to what is new, flexible to change: these are the Bergoglian perspectives of ecclesial mutation, so that, he says, the Church may be in all regions of the earth in a state of permanent mission. These are directives and orientations that the bishops themselves must embody and promote.
The synod of bishops, thus conceived as the exemplary expression of an entirely synodal Church, is therefore reshaped around psychological truisms, functional to the construction of relationships that are purely horizontal, even if draped in Gospel language. To invite, for example, the bishop to listen to his Church through consultative bodies of participation is like telling a fish that it must swim to live. But to make people believe that conversion to the synodal method is equivalent to conversion to Christ, to His word, and to the will of God: this is a deception pure and simple.
Bergoglio’s formation, according to which «it is precisely the synodal path that is the path God expects of the Church of the third millennium,» is idolatrous, for Bergoglio places himself in the place of God. Moreover, when he claims to know with certainty what God expects of the Church of the third millennium — namely, the synodal path — he not only presumes to know in advance the will of God for the contemporary Church, but he denies and contradicts the very essence and meaning of the synodal method, imposing it from above as the eleventh divine commandment.
In other words, Bergoglio asserts that God wills the synodal path. Period. This fact is not up for discussion. Whoever accepts synodality does the will of God; whoever rejects it opposes the will of God and places himself outside the Church. Evidently, the concept and style of synodality are imposed by God upon all believers, bishops first and foremost. Bergoglio and, today, his successor, also an antipope, Prevost, are excluded from this.
Whoever has usurped the petrine throne employs the synodal method as a puppeteer who pulls the strings of his marionettes: an elaborate instrument of ecclesiastical governance and of power over consciences that, in the general and contagious torpor of intelligence, opposes the canonical role of the synod of bishops and erases it entirely. Yet no one wishes to open their eyes to this evidence, and very few raise their voices.
The Church that, in Bergoglio’s idea, is constitutively synodal, in fact legitimizes itself in the eyes of Bergoglio — and, he claims, in the eyes of God — as the Church of Christ only if it carries forward the synodal process from this millennium onward. But the price to be paid is high: one must reject revelation, break with tradition, alter Catholic doctrine, and render even the precepts of divine law optional.
Perhaps my interpretation is biased by an anti-Bergoglio prejudice. There is no doubt, however, that those bishops, cardinals, and theologians whom Bergoglio has elected, created, appointed, and convened to carry out his reforms are the first, the most faithful, and the most obedient supporters of his unwholesome and heretical ideas, capable of manipulating theological, canonical, and biblical sources in order to present to the public an apparent continuity with Catholic tradition.
Theological Justifications for the Reform
Thus, for example, Archbishop Baldisseri, created a cardinal by Bergoglio in 2014, when officially presenting this document, Episcopalis communio, in the Vatican, openly declared: «This is the factor of greatest novelty in the new apostolic constitution, expounded above all from number 5, a factor that in certain respects configures a true refounding of the synodal organism. I refer to the stable framing of the synod within the framework of a constitutively synodal Church.»
This point of view is confirmed, on the same occasion, by Professor Dario Vitali, appointed by Bergoglio in 2023 as coordinator of the theological experts of the sixteenth general assembly of the synod of bishops. In a manipulative manner, citing a phrase of St. John Chrysostom already used by Bergoglio — according to which Church and synod are synonymous — he said: «If this overlap is true, then one must speak of a constitutively synodal Church and of synodality as the binding form in which the ecclesial communio is expressed.»
«One might say, with a touch of audacity, that the apostolic constitution Episcopalis communio aims to regulate immediately the celebration of synodal assemblies, while having as its horizon a Church entirely synodal toward which we are all called to journey. Indeed, the celebration of the synod becomes in a certain way an image and model of the Church itself, which is called to order its entire life according to the synodal principle of mutual listening at all levels of its existence.»
St. John Chrysostom: A Questionable Citation
If, however, we go to verify the source, we realize that in his commentary on Psalm 149, verse 1 — «Sing to the Lord a new song, His praise in the assembly of the faithful» — St. John Chrysostom first speaks of the Eucharist, that is, of thanksgiving to God through the death and resurrection of Christ, which is realized in the sacrament. Then he speaks of joyful acclamation of praise, then of symphony, as a harmonious meeting of voices and music.
This is followed by the word systema, which indicates the complete and orderly organization of the ecclesial body; only at the end does the term synodos appear, which would therefore be a great reduction to translate simply as «walking together,» while it would be more correct to render it as «walking together with Christ.» For He, in fact, is the true subject implied here, but clearly revealed by the Gospel, without Whom the Church does not even exist.
The phrase, of which Bergoglio and then Vitali cite a reduced and incomplete synthesis, in its fullness would be: «Eia gar systema, synodou estin onoma.» That is: «The name of the Church is systema and synodos,» an expression that already sounds quite different from the phrase reported by Bergoglio and his theologian: «Church and synod are synonymous.» Indeed, we would say that its meaning is entirely different.
For Chrysostom, the Eucharist, joy, choral harmony, and charity are elements that constitute the reality called Church. Therefore, the phrase of Chrysostom, literally «the name of the Church is systema and synodos,» in light of the text and context should be translated: «The Church is a well-organized body,» which forms a harmonious whole. In no case, however, should it be translated with the poor and tendentious version «Church and synod are synonymous,» which Bergoglio and Vitali have attributed to St. John Chrysostom.
Thus, despite the attempt to legitimize with the aid of patristic theology the idea and form of a constitutively synodal Church, precisely in light of Chrysostom’s passage, this walking together or walking together with the characteristics of welcome, inclusivity, and mutual listening — which in Bergoglio’s mind redefine the synodal ministry of the bishops and identify the style, method, and content of the process of the synodal Church — in reality has nothing in itself to do with the tradition of the Fathers nor does it describe anything properly Christian.
For it is not the walking together or the walking together of laity, priests, and bishops that creates synodality. The passage from chapter 2 of the Gospel of Luke, where the only use of the word «synod» is found to describe the caravan of pilgrims returning from Jerusalem to Nazareth, emphasizes the wandering of a community in which Jesus, then twelve years old, is absent, for He remained in the temple, attending to the things of His Father.
This fact is emblematic. It tells us that walking together in intentions and in the same direction, side by side but without Christ, entails not being in the things and in the will of the Father. Where the encounter in Christ is lacking, where walking with Christ and in Christ is lacking, in the Church ordered under the guidance of the bishops and united to its Lord, the very sense of walking, which for the believer is always, first and foremost, following and obeying his own Lord and doing the will of the Father, is lost.
Conclusion: A Break with Apostolic Succession
To recap, the synod of bishops, transformed by Bergoglio into a group of mutual support and a stable organ of counsel for the people of God, assumes the physiognomy and prerogatives of a permanent synod. Yet, since the relationship with the person of Christ, the one and universal Savior, is diminished and His commandments are not obeyed, Bergoglio’s reform creates an anti-Catholic assembly that, instead of promoting the Gospel and the orthodoxy of the faith, alters from within the Catholic creed.
In conclusion, Bergoglio, by effectively remaking the Church starting from the transformation of its constitutive element and indispensable guide — Peter with the other apostles — delivers into the hands of the Antichrist those believers who follow the synodal path.
And it is precisely in this way that Bergoglio’s and Prevost’s synodal Church, already schismatic from Pope Benedict XVI through his declaratio and his entry into an impeded sede, officially configures itself as another subject, no longer bound to apostolic succession and revelation.
The deception for the faithful lies in the fact that this synodal Church, while preserving the outward appearance and structures of the Catholic Church, empties and replaces within itself the content of the faith as the synodal process advances.
The present reflection concludes here. In the next catechesis, the juridical, theological, and practical consequences of the synodal revolution of the Church, born of the mind of Bergoglio, will be presented in detail.
Praised be Jesus Christ, always.
Don Franco Brogi