When Cardinal Joseph Bernardin, the archbishop of Newark, died in 1996, Theodore Edgar McCarrick wrote of having lost a « good and holy » priest friend.
McCarrick went down in history as a sexual abuser and close friend of Jorge Mario Bergoglio, who managed to get himself elected Pope precisely thanks to the excellent relations between the White House and the archbishop of Newark.
McCarrick was denounced for his red-light parties first in November 2000 by Nuncio Montalvo and a second time in 2006 by the delegate for Pontifical Representations Msgr. Viganò. Although McCarrick was cornered in 2017 by the trial for abuse of minors dating back to 1970 and dismissed from the clerical state in 2019, the « beloved Pope Francis » has always covered for him, proving himself a diligent defender of serial sexual abusers.
One of McCarrick's victims, James Grein, stated that in 1977 he was sexually assaulted by Bernardin in a house on the shores of Geneva Lake, Wisconsin, precisely where McCarrick abused seminarians. In 1993, in The Catholic Advocate, McCarrick wrote an article expressing his full solidarity with the « false accusations » made against his friend. Naturally, in their complicity, McCarrick and Bernardin sought to defend each other from every charge.
On the occasion of the 25th anniversary of the Catholic University Santo Toribio de Mogrovejo, on October 14, 2023, Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost was awarded a doctorate honoris causa, and his entire speech focused on the laudable ethical initiatives of Cardinals Bernardin and Cupich. Prevost recalled Bernardin's historic speech at Fordham University in 1983, hailing it as a turning point in the history of the Church in the United States, because it offered a new way of thinking about and addressing ethical issues and the value of human life. We must defend the lives of the weakest – continued the cardinal citing Bernardin – human life must be defended and protected; whoever is against abortion but in favor of capital punishment is not consistent with the social doctrine of the Church.
When journalists asked Leo XIV last September what he thought of the award that Cupich intended to give to super-abortionist Democratic Senator Richard Durbin, he first said he knew nothing about it, and then answered exactly as Bernardin would have: « Someone who says, 'I am opposed to abortion but in favor of capital punishment,' is not really pro-life. Similarly, someone who says, 'I am opposed to abortion but agree with the inhumane treatment of immigrants,' I do not know if they can be called pro-life » (due to shame, the synodal church had the interview video removed from the web).
The successor of Chicago's archbishop Bernardin, Cardinal Blase Cupich, on October 16, 2026 delivered a Lectio in honor of his predecessor, published in full by Vatican News. Cupich took up Bernardin's historic 1983 address, with which Bernardin introduced his famous approach to the « consistent ethic of life ». Cupich stated: « The theological and moral legacy of Cardinal Joseph Bernardin remains one of the most influential currents of thought in modern American Church social doctrine… I pray that the prophetic voice and legacy of our beloved Cardinal Bernardin, still timely, will continue to inspire all of us to even deeper mutual solidarity ».
On Father David Nix's blog, an interview was reported with an eighty-year-old woman calling herself Agnes, who claims to have been raped by Bernardin during a satanic ritual that occurred in 1957, when she was 11 years old: « Father Bernardin took me into his lap, telling me I had been a good girl, that this had been a test and that I had behaved well. I began to cry and relaxed, loosening my extreme resistance. It was then that he raped me, saying he was introducing the devil inside me… After that, he committed a sacrilege using what he called a consecrated Host, forcing me to ingest it ».
Why did the woman decide to speak up only now? The first reason was to defend her own life and that of her relatives; the second was this: « Growing up, I heard from my relatives that one day Cardinal Bernardin would be canonized ».
The interview was reported by LifeSiteNews last November 5. Agnes stated that, for fear of retaliation, she found no lawyer able to defend her: « A lawyer finally agreed to represent me, but warned me that if I made the matter public, the lives of my entire family would be destroyed ». The woman confided in Father Malachi Martin, who, under the alias Agnes, included the satanic ritual of which she was a victim in his 1996 novel Windswept House. Agnes adds: « Malachi Martin promised to get my testimony directly to John Paul II (which I took for granted, since he had reported a question asked by the Pope to me) ».
Father David Nix reiterates in the article: « I am 100% certain that last week I dined with Bernardin's victim, dating back to 1957. Today, she decides to break a silence that has lasted years, driven by recent attempts to 'canonize' Bernardin ».
By lighting several candles in front of the 14-meter-high statue of Leo XIV recently erected near Lima, and through the powerful intercession of Theodore Edgar McCarrick, will our abortionist Cardinal Blase Cupich succeed in having his alleged sexual abuser friend Joseph Bernardin canonized?