We have never accepted that questions of such magnitude could be dismissed with a hasty formula, labelled as conspiracy theories, or met with the mere delegitimisation of those who raise them. These matters deserve juridical answers, not summary judgments.
FIRST KNOT: BENEDICT XVI’S RESIGNATION
Everything begins on 11 February 2013, when Benedict XVI pronounced his Declaratio, announcing his resignation from the ministerium of Bishop of Rome, Successor of Saint Peter, effective from 28 February.
Canon 332 § 2 of the Code of Canon Law stipulates that, for the validity of the resignation of the Roman Pontiff, it must be freely made and duly manifested.
Since then, we have posed a fundamental question: is the formulation used by Benedict XVI, the distinction between munus and ministerium, and the circumstances surrounding that declaration fully compatible with the canonical requirements for resignation?
This is not a marginal linguistic issue. It concerns whether the Petrine office was effectively renounced or whether the declaration produced juridical consequences different from those commonly attributed to it.
From this question arises a historically significant query: if the resignation did not validly produce the vacancy of the Apostolic See, what consequences would this have for the subsequent election of Jorge Mario Bergoglio?
SECOND KNOT: THE ELECTION OF FRANCIS
If doubts exist regarding the validity of the act that would have determined the vacancy of the Apostolic See, it becomes inevitable to scrutinise the regularity of the 2013 conclave and the legitimacy of the authority that emerged from it.
The issue cannot be resolved simply by invoking the passage of time, institutional recognition, or the widespread acceptance of the election. The original problem must be addressed on the plane of canon law.
We have insisted that the arguments be examined on their merits, without prejudice and without transforming dissent into a fault.
THIRD KNOT: THE CARDINALS CREATED BY FRANCIS AND THE LEGITIMACY OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE
Here, a further question arises, one that could have extraordinary consequences. During his pontificate, Francis has created numerous cardinals, many of whom participated in the May 2025 conclave that elected Leo XIV.
But if the original invalidity of Francis’s election were to be established, what would be the juridical status of the acts of cardinalatial creation he issued? This is a question we cannot evade.
Canon 349 of the Code of Canon Law assigns to the College of Cardinals the task of electing the Roman Pontiff. Canon 351 governs the creation of cardinals by the Roman Pontiff.
The problem, therefore, is directly linked to the legitimacy of the authority that conferred such dignity upon them and, above all, to the juridical title under which they exercised the right to vote.
If Francis had not been legitimately invested with the Petrine office, it would be necessary to determine what consequences such a circumstance would produce regarding the acts of cardinalatial creation and the status of the cardinals he appointed.
We are not asserting that the consequence must automatically be the nullity of the appointments or of the subsequent election. We maintain that the problem must be addressed and resolved through a rigorous analysis of the applicable canonical norms.
The issue becomes even more relevant when one considers that the College of Cardinals is the body entrusted with electing the Successor of Peter.
FOURTH KNOT: LEO XIV AND DOUBTS SURROUNDING THE REGULARITY OF THE 2025 CONCLAVE
With the death of Francis and the election of Leo XIV, the problem takes on a new dimension. The legitimacy of the succession cannot be examined without considering the issues surrounding the previous election and the composition of the College of Cardinals.
To this is added the circumstances surrounding the May 2025 conclave. The interview with Father Bruno Silvestrini, published by Cronache Maceratesi on 11 May 2025, brought to public attention statements regarding the prior knowledge of information about the election of Robert Prevost.
From this emerged a further initiative: the canonical petition of 8 April 2026 addressed to Cardinal Pietro Parolin, in which we submitted to ecclesiastical authority possible violations of articles 44, 48, 55, and 56 of the Apostolic Constitution Universi Dominici Gregis.
We have asked for verification as to whether there were violations of the provisions on secrecy, the isolation of the conclave, and the prohibition of external communications, and, above all, whether any irregularities had a concrete impact on the freedom and validity of the election.
We have not transformed a rumour into proof. We have asked for the facts to be ascertained.
A CHAIN OF LEGITIMACY THAT WARRANTS EXAMINATION
This is the central point of our initiative. We are not dealing with isolated questions, but with issues that are interconnected and must be addressed in their entirety:
Did Benedict XVI’s resignation validly produce the vacancy of the Apostolic See?
Was Francis’s election based on a valid vacancy of the See and in accordance with canonical norms?
What consequences would an eventual invalidity of Francis’s election have on the acts of cardinalatial creation he performed?
Did the cardinals whose creation was potentially contested have the right to participate in the election of the new Pope?
Was the composition of the College of Cardinals that elected Leo XIV in conformity with canonical provisions?
Did the circumstances of the 2025 conclave respect all the guarantees set forth in Universi Dominici Gregis?
These are questions that pertain to the institutional continuity of the Church, the apostolic succession, and the legitimacy of pontifical authority.
We do not claim to substitute ourselves for the competent ecclesiastical authority. We do, however, insist that it exercise its responsibilities and provide documented responses.
SILENCE CANNOT SUBSTITUTE FOR THE LAW
The Church is a spiritual institution, but it is also a juridical order. Canon law is not an accessory element, nor a set of provisions that can be interpreted only when convenient.
The norms governing the resignation of the Pope, the creation of cardinals, and the election of his successor represent fundamental guarantees for the continuity of the Church.
For this reason, we believe that the questions raised cannot be dismissed through silence. We are not asking anyone to share our conclusions in advance. We are asking that our arguments be examined, that juridically grounded responses be provided, and that ecclesiastical authorities finally address the issue.
What is not in question is the faith of believers. What is not in question is the respect owed to the Church. What is in question is the necessity that even the highest ecclesiastical authorities respect the norms governing their own legitimacy.
Together with Andrea Cionci and all those who have shared this journey, we will continue to demand truth, transparency, and clarity.
This is not a battle against a man. This is not a battle against the Church. It is a battle so that the Church may, through a review of its recent history, regain the full credibility of its authority.
For if apostolic succession represents one of the foundations of the Church’s continuity, the regularity of its transmission cannot be considered a secondary detail.
THIS IS NOT A BATTLE AGAINST A POPE.
IT IS A BATTLE FOR THE TRUTH ABOUT THE LEGITIMACY OF THE PAPACY.
TRUTH IS NOT DEFENDED BY IMPOSING SILENCE.
IT IS DEFENDED BY ANSWERING QUESTIONS.
AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO ASK THEM.